Table of Contents
Obtaining the best finish for your woodwork project can be a daunting task, especially when the choice between Gel Stain and Oil Stain is involved. While both products will provide an even coloring for the application, there are some key differences that need to be taken into consideration before making a decision. Let’s take a look at Gel Stain vs Oil Stain, their features and uses, to help you make an informed decision.
When it comes to gel stains vs oil stains, there are several characteristics that distinguish one from the other. Gel stains provide a thicker and more intense color that is easy to apply, but they can be difficult to paint over and are not often recommended for outdoor surfaces. Oil stains provide a natural look with superior protection, but they require more time and effort to apply due to the oil-based formula.
Each of the different types of stains has its own unique advantages and disadvantages, so it is important to consider the desired end result and overall effect before choosing. Keep in mind the level of protection and durability you need, as well as the ease of application and cleanup process as more factors to consider. With all this in mind, you should have a better understanding of the differences between gel stain vs oil stain and be able to make an informed decision for your woodworking projects.
What is Gel Stain?
Just like the name suggests, Gel Stain is a thick, viscous substance that contains oils and high concentrations of binders that works by penetrating into the grain of the wood, creating a uniform color that is more resistant to bleeding and streaking than traditional oil stains.
Gel stain also provides a rich, deep-looking finish without having to apply multiple coats. It leaves a thin layer of tint that makes the wood look like it was stained and painted. However, it is not commonly used due to its thick consistency, which can make it more difficult to use.
Features of Gel Stain
To set it apart from other stains, Gel Stain features a few unique properties. Here are some of them.
- High Viscosity: The high viscosity of Gel Stain makes it ideal for vertical surfaces as the viscous consistency will help it stick to the surface and not drip or run down.
- Clear color: Gel Stains are clear, meaning that they will not alter the natural color of the wood, allowing for more control and customization over the final look.
- Non-fading: Gel Stains are non-fading, meaning they will not fade over time like traditional oil stains. This makes it a good choice for outdoor projects or surfaces that are exposed to sunlight.
Examples of Gel Stains and Their Characteristic
Miniwax
The brand Miniwax offers a wide range of Gel Stains, each with its own unique characteristics.
- Dark Walnut: A dark, rich brown stain that is ideal for any indoor or outdoor woodworking project.
- Early American: An iconic shade that gives the wood a warm and classic look. Perfect for traditional furniture projects.
- Gunstock: A dark, reddish-brown stain that adds a rustic touch to any wood project.
Varathene
Varathene also offers a range of Gel Stains for woodworking projects.
- Cherrywood: An intense, reddish-brown stain that adds depth and character to any piece.
- Ebony: A deep black finish that gives the wood an unmistakable elegance.
Pros and Cons of Gel Stains
Gel Stains are a great option for woodworking projects. Here are some of the pros and cons of Gel Stains:
Pros:
– Easy to apply and clean up.
– Provides a uniform color without having to apply multiple coats.
– Resistant to fading, streaking, and weathering.
– Non-toxic and safe to use indoors.
Cons :
– Difficult to work with due to its thick consistency.
– May require special applicators or brushes for proper application.
– Not ideal for use on unfinished wood surfaces.
– Can be difficult to achieve a consistent color with multiple applications.
How to Apply Gel Stains
When it comes to application, the highly viscous consistency of Gel Stains can make it difficult to use. Here is a quick guide for a successful application:
Step One: Prep the Wood Surface
Before applying Gel Stains, the wood should be prepared properly by sanding and cleaning the surface with a damp cloth.
Step Two: Use an Applicator or Brush
To ensure even coverage and reduce the risk of streaks, a brush or an applicator should be used to apply the stain. However, when using a brush
Step Three: Apply in Thin Layers
Gel Stains should be applied in thin layers, as multiple coats can cause uneven coloring and streaking.
Step Four: Allow Drying Time
After application, it is important to let the stain dry thoroughly before adding a second coat. Be sure to check the manufacturer’s instructions for specific drying times.
Oil Stains
Oil stains are traditional wood-finishing products that work by penetrating into the surface of the wood to create an attractive, long-lasting finish. Basically, oil stains are a combination of pigment, oil, and thinner that all work together to stain wood. The type of oil used is usually either linseed or tung oil.
Oil stains can be used to create a wide variety of colors, from light yellow/amber tones to dark browns and even black. They also offer a wide range of sheen levels, from matte to high gloss.
Feature of Oil Stains
Some of the distinguishing features of oil stains include:
– Penetrates deep into the wood for a more durable finish.
– Flexible and resistant to chipping, cracking, and peeling.
– Easy to apply and clean up.
– Provides a natural look and feel to the wood.
Pros and Cons of Oil Stains
Pros:
– Easy to apply and clean up.
– Provides a natural look and feel to the wood.
– Flexible and resistant to chipping, cracking, and peeling.
– Penetrates deep into the wood for a more durable finish.
Cons :
Oil stains offer many advantages, especially in terms of longevity and protection. However, there are a few drawbacks to consider:
– Requires more maintenance than other finishes.
– Not ideal for use on unfinished wood surfaces.
– Oil stains can be difficult to match.
– Can be susceptible to moisture damage.
Types of Oil Stains
Exterior Oil-Based Stains
Exterior oil stains are designed to provide color and protection against the elements. They can be used on decks, fences, siding, and outdoor furniture.
Some of the common brands of exterior oil stains include:
– Ready Seal
– Miniwax
– Rust-Oleum
Interior Oil-Based Stains
Interior oil stains are used for indoor woodworking projects, such as cabinets, furniture, and trim.
Some of the common brands of interior oil stains include:
– Minwax
– SamaN
– Cabot
How to Apply Oil Stains
Oil stains can provide a unique and attractive look for woodworking projects, but to achieve this you must ensure proper application. Here’s a quick guide to applying an oil stain correctly:
Step One: Prep the Wood Surface
Before application, it is important to inspect the wood surface for any defects or dirt and sand it down as needed. This will ensure a smooth and even finish on the stain.
Step Two: Apply the Oil Stain
Once the surface is prepped, you can begin to apply the stain. Start in an inconspicuous area and work your way outward, using a brush or cloth to apply the stain evenly.
Step Three: Allow Time to Dry
After applying the oil stain, it needs time to dry and penetrate the wood. The drying time varies, depending on various factors but typically ranges from two to four hours.
Step Four: Sand and Reapply as Needed
Once the stain has dried, it is important to sand the surface lightly to remove any excess residue. If more color is desired, simply reapply another layer of stain following the same steps as before.
Gel Stain Vs Oil Stain: Summary of Differences
Now that we have looked at each type of stain in detail, let’s take a look at the main differences between them.
Appearance
Gel stains are thicker and offer a more intense color, whereas oil stains provide a more subtle, natural look. Further, gel stains are easier to apply, as they do not require sanding between coats.
Durability
Oil stains penetrate deep into the wood, providing a more durable finish that resists chipping, cracking, and peeling. On the other hand, gel stains are usually thinner and provide less protection against the elements because they do not penetrate as deeply.
Cleanup
Oil stains are easy to clean up, typically requiring only soap and water. Gel stains, however, are more difficult to remove and usually require mineral spirits for a complete cleanup since they harden on contact.
Maintenance
Oil stains require more maintenance than gel stains, as they must be reapplied and touched up periodically to maintain their appearance. Gel stains create a hard and smooth surface after it has completely dried and is less likely to trap dirt or require frequent touchups.
Uses
Gel stains are ideal for interior woodworking projects, such as cabinets and furniture. This is because they provide a thick and vivid color that is easy to apply. On the other hand, oil stains are best suited for outdoor projects, such as decks and fences, as they provide a natural look and superior protection against the elements.
Gel stain vs Oil stain: Choosing the Right Stain
Since you know the differences between gel and oil stains, it’s time to decide which one is best for your project. Both provide excellent protection and attractive finishes, but the type of stain you choose will depend on the desired look, ease of application, and durability.
When you are looking for a thick, intense color that is easy to apply, then a gel stain may be the best option. On the other hand, if you prefer a more natural look with superior protection, then an oil stain is the way to go. Ultimately, the best option is up to you and your unique project needs.
Here are some tips to help you decide:
- Consider the desired look and overall effect before choosing a stain.
- Take into account the ease of application and the amount of time needed to complete the project.
- Think about the level of protection and durability you need for your particular project.
- Pay attention to the cleanup process and what type of materials are needed for it.
- Compare the cost of both stains, as well as any additional products that may be needed.
Gel stain vs Oil stain: FAQs
Are Gel Stains Water-based or Oil-based?
Gel stains are arguably considered to be oil-based due to their composition, but some products may also be listed as water-based for easy cleanup without the need for mineral spirits. So, it is important to double-check the product label before purchasing.
Can Gel Stains Be Used on Exterior Surfaces?
In general, gel stains are better suited for interior projects since they are usually thinner and do not penetrate as deeply. They can be used on the exterior, but it is important to ensure the surface is sealed with a good quality sealer or varnish. Gel stains are also not as waterproof and may require more frequent reapplication than oil stains when used on the exterior.
Can I Apply Gel Stain Over Oil Stain?
Yes, you can apply gel stains over oil-based stains. It is important to ensure the surface is properly prepared first, though, as oil-based stains can be difficult to adhere to. Sanding the surface and cleaning it thoroughly before applying the gel stain will ensure better adhesion. Additionally, if the oil-based stain is a pale color, it may be necessary to apply a primer before applying the gel stain for optimal results.
Can I Paint Over Gel Stains?
Generally, Gel stains are not designed to be painted over as they are usually very thick and can easily crack or chip if not applied correctly. If you are determined to paint over a gel stain, it is best to use latex-based paint. Keep in mind that the final results may not have the desired effect, as the consistency of the gel stain will likely influence how well the paint adheres.
Conclusion
Gel and oil stains both provide excellent protection and attractive finishes, but the type of stain you choose will depend on the desired look, ease of application, and durability. Gel stains are ideal for interior woodworking projects due to their thick and vivid coloring that is easy to apply. On the other hand, oil stains are best suited for both indoor and outdoor projects, as they provide a more natural look and superior protection against the elements. Ultimately, the best option is up to you and your unique project needs.
