Table of Contents
Polyurethane is a popular type of finish used on many different types of surfaces, including wood floors, furniture, and cabinets. When it comes to choosing the right type of polyurethane, the two main options are water-based and oil-based. Both have their advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important to understand the differences between them to make an informed decision. In this article, we’ll explore the 10 main differences between polyurethane water vs oil.
What is Water-Based Polyurethane?
Water-based polyurethane is a type of finish that is made from synthetic resins and water. It has a milky appearance when applied but dries clear. It’s typically low in odor and dries quickly. Water-based polyurethane is also known for its durability, as it provides a strong protective barrier against wear and tear, scratches, and moisture.
Although applying water-based polyurethane can prove to be more demanding than oil-based, it is worth the cost and effort. It provides better protection in humid climates compared to its alternative, yet one downside is that this type of product tends to raise the grain which requires further sanding.
What is Oil-Based Polyurethane?
Oil-based polyurethane, on the other hand, is made from synthetic resins and mineral spirits or other solvents. It has a clear, amber appearance when applied, which can darken over time. Oil-based polyurethane is known for its ease of application and the deep, rich finish it provides. It’s also more resistant to high-humidity environments than water-based polyurethane.
However, oil-based polyurethane has a stronger odor and a longer drying time. It can also yellow over time and may require more frequent reapplication than water-based polyurethane.
Specialty Polyurethane
These finishes offer unique properties and finishes that can be tailored to specific projects.
High-Gloss Polyurethane
High-gloss polyurethane is a glossy, reflective finish perfect for surfaces that need to be sturdy and long-lasting. Hardwood floors or high-traffic areas are great options due to its durability, while the ease of cleaning makes them ideal for rooms needing frequent upkeep.
Matte Polyurethane
For a more rustic, aged look that still retains its natural texture and color, matte polyurethane is an ideal solution. It’s perfect for furniture or cabinetry that needs to have a flat, non-reflective surface while displaying the wood’s unique grain and colors. With this type of finish applied, you’ll be sure to achieve an aesthetically pleasing result without taking away from the beauty of your wooden pieces.
Satin Polyurethane
Satin polyurethane is a lustrous finish that offers the perfect balance between shimmering gloss and flat matte. Ideal for furniture surfaces where you want to maintain an elegant yet understated look, such as wood countertops or cabinets; satin polyurethane gives off just enough of a glossy gleam without being too attention-grabbing.
UV-Resistant Polyurethane
Make sure your outdoor furniture stays in top condition for years to come with a UV-resistant polyurethane finish. Able to prevent yellowing and fading, this special coating is designed to withstand the harsh rays of the sun that are known for causing discoloration on wooden surfaces.
Moisture-Cured Polyurethane
Moisture-cured polyurethane is a finish that hardens when exposed to moisture in the atmosphere, making it ideal for areas with high humidity or surfaces that are frequently subjected to water exposure, such as wooden decks or bathroom cabinets.
How to Choose the Right Type of Polyurethane for Your Project
When choosing the right type of polyurethane for your project, there are several factors to consider. Here are six important points to keep in mind:
- Consider the type of surface you’ll be applying the polyurethane to.
- Think about the level of durability you’ll need.
- Determine the desired finish, such as high-gloss or matte.
- Consider the environment the surface will be in, such as high humidity or direct sunlight.
- Consider the level of odor and drying time.
- Think about the ease of application and whether you’ll need professional assistance.
Polyurethane Water Vs Oil: Staining and Coloring
Staining and coloring polyurethane can have a significant impact on the final appearance of the finish. Here are six ways in which staining and coloring can affect the appearance of polyurethane:
Hue
Polyurethane can be transformed with staining and coloring, from lightening the shade to developing an entirely new color. An application of yellow stain on wood flooring, for example, produces a gorgeous golden hue while red stain gives off an inviting reddish tone.
Transparency
Stains and coloring agents can be added to polyurethane to make it more or less transparent. This can impact the visibility of the wood grain or other natural characteristics of the surface.
Depth
Staining and coloring can add depth to the appearance of the polyurethane finish. This can create a rich, three-dimensional appearance that highlights the natural beauty of the wood or other surface.
Uniformity
Stains and coloring can be used to create a uniform appearance across the surface. This can be particularly useful when working with wood that has a lot of natural variation in color or grain pattern.
Texture
Stains and coloring can also impact the texture of the polyurethane finish. For example, a heavily pigmented color may create a more opaque, painted look, while a lighter stain may create a more natural, wood-like texture.
Durability
The durability of the polyurethane finish can also be impacted by the type of stain or coloring used. Some pigments and dyes may be more prone to fading or discoloration over time, which can impact the overall appearance of the finish.
Polyurethane Water Vs Oil: Effects of Staining and Coloring on Polyurethane
When it comes to comparing the results of staining and coloring water-based and oil-based polyurethane, there are several important differences to consider:
Absorption
Water-based polyurethane tends to absorb stains and coloring agents differently than oil-based polyurethane. Water-based finishes typically require more coats to achieve the desired depth of color.
Drying Time
Water-based polyurethane typically dries faster than oil-based polyurethane, which can impact the final appearance of the finish. With water-based finishes, there is less time to work with the stain or coloring agent before it dries.
Color
The type of stain or coloring agent used can impact the final color of the polyurethane finish. Some colors may appear differently on water-based versus oil-based finishes.
Clarity
Water-based polyurethane tends to have a more clear appearance than oil-based polyurethane, which can impact the final appearance of the stained or colored finish.
Odor
Water-based polyurethane has a significantly lower odor than oil-based polyurethane, which can make it more appealing for indoor projects where strong odors are a concern.
Polyurethane Water Vs Oil: The 10 Differences
Polyurethane is available in two different formulations: water-based and oil-based. While both types of polyurethane protect the wood, they have some significant differences in their characteristics, including:
- Drying Time: Water-based polyurethane has a much shorter drying time compared to oil-based polyurethane. Water-based polyurethane dries in a few hours, while oil-based polyurethane takes much longer to dry, usually between 12 and 24 hours.
- Color: Water-based polyurethane has a clear, transparent finish that does not yellow with age. Oil-based polyurethane, on the other hand, has an amber or golden color that deepens with age, which can be desirable or not depending on the project.
- Odor: Water-based polyurethane has a minimal odor, while oil-based polyurethane has a strong smell that can last for several days. The odor can be a significant issue for people with respiratory issues or those who are sensitive to strong smells.
- Durability: Oil-based polyurethane is more durable than water-based polyurethane, making it more resistant to scratches and abrasions. However, water-based polyurethane is still relatively durable and can be an excellent choice for low-traffic areas.
- Level of Toxicity: Water-based polyurethane has a lower level of toxicity compared to oil-based polyurethane, making it a safer option for indoor use. Oil-based polyurethane contains higher levels of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which can be harmful to your health and the environment.
- Ease of Application: Water-based polyurethane is easy to apply and clean up since it is water-based, while oil-based polyurethane requires mineral spirits or other solvents to clean up. The cleanup process is much more challenging and time-consuming, making water-based polyurethane the better option for DIY projects.
- Price: Water-based polyurethane is generally more expensive than oil-based polyurethane, making it a better option for high-end projects.
- Appearance: Water-based polyurethane provides a clear, transparent finish that highlights the natural beauty of the wood, while oil-based polyurethane provides a rich amber color that can deepen the color of the wood.
- Maintenance: Water-based polyurethane requires less maintenance than oil-based polyurethane, making it a better option for high-traffic areas. Water-based polyurethane is easy to clean and can withstand repeated cleaning, while oil-based polyurethane requires more maintenance to keep it looking good.
- Environmental Impact: Water-based polyurethane has a lower environmental impact compared to oil-based polyurethane since it contains fewer VOCs. Water-based polyurethane is also less flammable and poses less of a risk of fire.
Related: Can You Apply Polyurethane With a Roller?
Polyurethane Water Vs Oil: VOC Regulations
Due to the negative impacts of Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) on human health and the environment, government regulations have been implemented to limit their emission from paint products such as polyurethane. These toxic chemicals evaporate at room temperature and can significantly reduce indoor air quality if not properly regulated. As such, we must adhere to these guidelines to protect our families and the planet.
Within the US, consumer and commercial products are regulated by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regarding their VOC emissions. The present federal maximum for clear wood finishes such as polyurethane is 350 g/L for oil-based items and 275 g/L for water-based ones. Moreover, states may impose more stringent VOC regulations compared to those established federally.
Water-based polyurethane is often the preferred choice in regions with stringent VOC regulations, like California, as it typically has lower VOC levels than oil-based products. This is because water-based items are composed of water while oil-based ones rely on mineral spirits or other solvents that contain higher levels of Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs).
It’s important to recognize, however, that not every water-based polyurethane product is equal when it comes to VOC levels. Certain producers might add co-solvents or other ingredients to enhance the capability of their products – this can increase the amount of VOCs present. To ensure you’re using a responsible and high-quality product for your project, be sure to double-check the label or safety data sheet for its specific VOC content before purchasing.
When investigating the VOC levels between water-based and oil-based polyurethane, it’s essential to remember that the permissible limit for water-based products is lower than those of oil-based ones. Thus, a specific water-based product may have higher VOC levels than an oil one yet still comply with regulatory guidelines. However, using goods with lower emissions will always be preferable for both air quality and our fragile environment.
Related: What’s The Difference Between Polycrylic And Polyurethane
Polyurethane Water Vs Oil: Application Techniques
Polyurethane application is a critical step in achieving a perfect finish. There are different application techniques for water-based and oil-based polyurethane, and each technique has its advantages and disadvantages, including:
Brushing: For a smooth and even finish, brushing is the most recommended technique for applying polyurethane. Utilizing natural bristle brushes to apply thin, controlled coats of this glossy substance can be done at your own pace. To practice this method, you will need only three items: a quality brush capable of retaining the product’s viscosity; an airtight container to store it in; and ample lighting so each stroke won’t go unnoticed.
Pros
- Provides more control over the application
- Can result in a smooth and even finish
Cons
- Can be time-consuming
- Can leave brush marks if not done correctly
Spraying: Polyurethane can also be applied using a spraying technique, which utilizes a spray gun to apply the product in thin layers. This is an efficient and simple method that ensures more even coverage of the polyurethane. However, it does require some special equipment – namely, a spray gun, air compressor for pressure control, container to hold the material, and finally, adequate ventilation as inhaling fumes must be avoided at all costs.
Pros
- Fast application
- Even distribution of the polyurethane
Cons
- Requires more equipment
- Can result in overspray and waste
Rolling: Rolling is the perfect way to quickly and evenly coat your project with polyurethane. To achieve this, you will need a high-quality roller, a receptacle for the product, as well as an adequate source of light to help guide your application. With rolling technique you can cover larger surfaces in less time than other methods – it’s simply efficient.
Pros
- Fast application
- Can cover large areas quickly
Cons
- Can result in an uneven finish
- Can leave roller marks if not done correctly
Wiping: To achieve a polished and even finish, wiping is the ideal approach. This process entails using a cloth to disperse the polyurethane in thin layers with great accuracy. It takes more time than other techniques, yet it will be worth it in the end! You’ll need to have on hand a high-quality cloth, an adequate container for your polyurethane, and ample illumination so you can monitor where you’re applying it.
Pros
- Provides more control over the application
- Can result in a smooth and even finish
Cons
- Can be time-consuming
- Can leave streaks if not done correctly
Troweling: Troweling allows for a precise and even application of polyurethane, yielding a glossy and smooth finish. For this method to be effective though, you must have the right tools: an excellent trowel, ample container for the product’s storage, and lighting that will help in seeing your progress. Although time-consuming compared with other approaches, it is most certainly worth every second spent.
Pros
- Provides more control over the application
- Can result in a smooth and even finish
Cons
- Can be time-consuming
- Can leave trowel marks if not done correctly
Relate: Is Water-Based Polyurethane Toxic?
Polyurethane Water Vs Oil: Safety Precautions
Polyurethane is a versatile and durable material that is commonly used as a wood finish. However, it can also be harmful to human health and safety if not used correctly. Therefore, it is important to take certain safety precautions when working with polyurethane to minimize the risks associated with its use.
Wearing Protective Gear
Polyurethane can be a hazardous material if not handled properly, so it’s essential to practice safety precautions. Don protective gear such as gloves, safety glasses, and a respirator while working with this substance. The gloves are there to safeguard your skin from contact with the polyurethane; wear the glasses for any splashes or fumes that may come about; and lastly, put on your respirator for extra defense against toxic vapors or dust particles present in its application process.
Proper Ventilation
It is imperative to ensure that the workspace is well-ventilated when applying polyurethane, as its released fumes can be detrimental to one’s health or even become explosive in higher concentrations. Being mindful of this potential danger will help protect yourself and others from any related respiratory issues.
Avoiding Open Flames
Polyurethane is highly flammable, so it’s essential to avoid open flames and smoking when working with the substance. Sparks from electrical equipment can also ignite polyurethane fumes, so caution should be taken when using such tools as well. To stay safe while dealing with this material, keep all sources of heat or spark away from the area.
Storing Polyurethane Properly
When not in use, it is vital to keep polyurethane out of reach from children and pets. It should be stored away from heat sources or open flames in a cool and dry place while enclosed within its original container. Remember, if ingested by either kids or animals, the outcome could be potentially hazardous.
Avoiding Skin Contact
Polyurethane can be dangerous to your skin, so it is essential to take protective measures when dealing with the material. Make sure you wear gloves and other safety apparel for maximum security. In case of contact, swiftly wash off the area with soap and water, or else inflammation may occur.
Using a Respirator
It is essential to bear in mind that wearing a respirator specifically designed for polyurethane, and using it correctly, can drastically reduce the amount of hazardous fumes and dust particles encountered while working with this substance.
Keeping Polyurethane Away from Children and Pets
To ensure the safety of your children and pets, make sure to keep polyurethane products out of their reach. Furthermore, if there are any spills or splashes from this substance, it is crucial to clean them up immediately to avert accidental ingestion.
Related: Applying Water-Based Polyurethane Over Oil-Based Stain: What You Need to Know
Polyurethane Water Vs Oil: Maintenance Tips
Polyurethane is a versatile and durable finish that can help protect and enhance the appearance of wood furniture, flooring, and other surfaces. However, even the most well-applied polyurethane finish will eventually require maintenance to keep it looking its best. Here are six key tips for maintaining your polyurethane finish:
- Regular Cleaning: To ensure your polyurethane finish remains vibrant and lasting, regular cleaning is a must. Dust, dirt, and other debris can accumulate on the surface to diminish its shine. A soft cloth or mop should be used for daily upkeep; however if there are tougher spots that need extra attention, opt for a mild cleansing solution instead of harsh chemicals which could damage the glossy exterior.
- Avoiding Abrasives: Polyurethane is durable, but it’s not invincible. Avoid using abrasive cleaning tools, such as steel wool or harsh scrub brushes, which can scratch or wear away the finish. Instead, use a soft cloth or gentle scrub pad to remove dirt and stains.
- Using Furniture Pads: Safeguard your polyurethane finish from scrapes and harm by using furniture pads on the legs of tables, chairs, and other furniture. Not only will these protect against damage in the present but they can also help to slow wear and tear over time.
- Protecting from Heat and Sunlight: Prolonged exposure to heat and sunlight can cause your polyurethane finish to deteriorate, becoming cracked or peeling. To protect it from harm, try not putting furniture or belongings near sources of heat like radiators and stoves, as well as in direct sunshine.
- Avoiding Moisture: To preserve the durability of polyurethane finishes, moisture must be avoided. Any liquid spills should immediately be wiped up and no wet items should rest upon its surface. Warping or bubbling can occur if exposed to too much water, so keep it far away from any potential sources to maintain a pristine finish.
- Refinishing When Needed: No matter how hard you work to maintain your polyurethane finish, it may eventually become worn and need a fresh look. If that’s the case, simply sand down the surface gently, remove any debris or dirt particles, then follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for applying a brand-new coat of polyurethane coating. By doing this simple process you can restore vibrancy to your furniture with ease.
Polyurethane Water Vs Oil: FAQs
Which type of polyurethane is better?
The answer to this question depends on your specific needs and preferences. Water-based polyurethane is generally considered more environmentally friendly and less toxic than oil-based polyurethane. It also dries faster and has less odor. However, oil-based polyurethane is more durable and tends to provide a richer and more consistent color. When choosing between the two, consider the application, the surface to be coated, and the look you are trying to achieve.
Can I mix water-based and oil-based polyurethane?
No, you should not mix water-based and oil-based polyurethane. The two types of polyurethane are not compatible and will not bond properly. Mixing them could lead to an uneven finish or even flaking and peeling. Stick to one type of polyurethane for your project.
How long does polyurethane last?
The lifespan of polyurethane depends on a variety of factors, such as the quality of the product, the surface it is applied, and the conditions it is exposed to. Generally, polyurethane can last anywhere from 5 to 10 years with proper care and maintenance. However, factors such as UV exposure, temperature changes, and moisture can shorten its lifespan.
How do I apply polyurethane?
The application of polyurethane depends on the specific product and surface you are working with. Generally, you will need to prepare the surface by sanding it down and cleaning it thoroughly. Then, apply the polyurethane using a brush, roller, or sprayer, following the manufacturer’s instructions. Be sure to apply thin and even coats, allowing each coat to dry fully before applying the next.
Can polyurethane be removed?
Yes, polyurethane can be removed through a process called sanding or stripping. Sanding involves using sandpaper or a sanding machine to remove the polyurethane layer by layer until the surface is restored. Stripping involves applying a chemical stripper to dissolve the polyurethane layer, which can then be scraped away. It is important to note that both methods can be time-consuming and messy, and should be done with caution to avoid damaging the underlying surface.
Is polyurethane safe for food surfaces?
Polyurethane is generally considered safe for food surfaces once it has fully cured and dried. However, it is important to use a food-grade polyurethane that is specifically labeled as safe for use on food surfaces. This will ensure that the polyurethane does not contain any harmful chemicals that could leach into food. Additionally, it is important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions for proper application and curing time to ensure that the polyurethane is fully cured and safe for food contact.
Polyurethane Water Vs Oil: Conclusion
Understanding the differences between polyurethane water vs oil is crucial for anyone who intends to work with polyurethane. Both types of polyurethane have their unique advantages and disadvantages, and it is essential to know them to choose the right type for your specific project needs. Additionally, you need to take appropriate safety precautions when working with polyurethane and maintain it correctly for longevity. With this knowledge, you can confidently work with polyurethane and achieve the desired results.
