Table of Contents
Varnish and stain are two popular finishes for wood that can protect and enhance the appearance of wood. When it comes to choosing between varnish and stain, there are a few important factors to consider. This article will explore the differences between varnish and stain, the pros and cons of each, and the ideal use cases for each. Ultimately, the choice between varnish vs stain will depend on the type of wood, the level of finish you’re going for, and the environment in which the finished piece will be in.
In any case, varnishing is a better option since it creates a protective barrier on your wood surface. Staining only improves the appearance or color without offering protection against wear and tear or extreme weather conditions.
One proven way to ensure the durability of wood items in your home is to treat them with a wood coating. This can be through applying paint, staining, or varnish. However, one question that comes into mind is varnish vs stain; which one is better? Knowing the difference between varnish vs stain will determine what’s best for your next woodworking project.
Difference Between Varnish and Stain
Varnish and stain serve different purposes, but they are both used to protect and enhance the appearance of wood. Varnish is a clear finish applied to the surface of the wood to provide a hard, durable layer of protection. It also enhances the natural color of the wood and provides a glossy finish.
Stain, on the other hand, is used to change the color of wood or enhance its natural color. It is a type of pigment absorbed into the wood and provides a more subtle finish. Unlike varnish, the stain does not provide a clear, protective layer. Instead, it penetrates the wood and provides a more natural, translucent look.
It is also important to remember that varnish can turn yellow over time, while stain will not. This may be something to consider if you are working with light-colored woods.
What is Varnish
Varnish is a clear wood coating that is applied to protect the surface of the wood. It comprises resins, oils, and solvents that work together to create a hard, durable finish. Varnish can be glossy or matte and range in different durability and sheen levels.
Characteristics of Varnish
- Clear, glossy finish
- A hard, durable layer of protection
- Enhances the natural color of wood
- It can be used on a variety of surfaces, including wood, metal, and plastic
What is Stain
A stain is a type of pigment absorbed into the wood to change its color or enhance its natural color. Unlike varnish, the stain does not provide a clear, protective layer. Instead, it provides a more natural, translucent look that allows the wood grain to show through.
Stain is a wood coating applied to improve the appearance of the wood. It penetrates the surface of the wood and does not create a protective barrier. Stain can be used to change the wood’s color or enhance the grain pattern.
Characteristics of Stain
- Stain penetrates the surface of the wood
- It provides a translucent color
- Enhances the natural color of wood
- It does not provide a clear, protective layer
RELATED: How Long Should Deck Stain Dry Before Walking On It?
Wood Stain vs Varnish: Pros and Cons
Wood Varnish Pros and Cons
Varnish is a type of protective finish for wood that provides a layer of clear or tinted protection over the surface. It is ideal for preserving the natural appearance of wood, as well as enhancing it. Here are some pros of using varnish on wood:
Durability: Varnish is known for its durability and resistance to moisture, heat, and UV rays. This makes it ideal for use in high-traffic areas, such as kitchen cabinets and table tops.
Long-lasting protection: Unlike other wood finishes, varnish can last many years without needing to reapply. This makes it a cost-effective solution for those looking to protect their wood surfaces.
Glossy finish: Varnish provides a glossy finish to wood, which enhances its natural beauty and can make it look more attractive. This is especially true for light-colored woods, such as maple or pine.
However, there are also some cons to using varnish on wood:
Drying time: Varnish takes a long time to dry and cure, which can be inconvenient for those looking for a quick solution. It is also important to allow the proper drying time between coats to ensure a smooth finish.
Yellowing: Over time, some varnish finishes can yellow, detracting from the wood’s natural appearance. This is especially true for light-colored woods.
Viscosity: Varnish is a thick and viscous liquid, which can be difficult to apply evenly. It can result in a streaky or blotchy finish if not applied properly.
Wood Stain Pros and Cons
Stain is a type of finish for wood that penetrates the surface and changes the color. Unlike varnish, it does not provide a layer of protection but enhances the wood’s natural grain. Here are some pros of using stain on wood:
Quick and easy: Staining is a quick and easy process compared to varnishing, and it can be completed in just a few hours. This makes it ideal for those who want to quickly enhance the color and appearance of their wood surfaces.
Versatility: Stain comes in a wide range of colors and finishes, from light and natural to dark and bold. This makes it ideal for those looking to change the color or appearance of their wood surfaces.
Cost-effective: Compared to varnish, the stain is a more cost-effective solution for those looking to enhance the appearance of their wood surfaces.
Some common cons to using stains on wood:
Lack of protection: Unlike varnish, the stain does not provide a layer of protection to the wood surface. This means that the wood will be more susceptible to damage from moisture, heat, and UV rays.
Short lifespan: Unlike varnish, the stain does not last as long and may need to be reapplied more frequently. This can be inconvenient for those looking for a long-lasting solution.
Poor application: If not applied properly, the stain can result in an uneven or blotchy finish, detracting from the wood’s natural beauty.
Wood Varnish vs Stain: Which is Better?
Choosing between unfinished outdoor furniture stain vs varnish depends on what you’re looking for. Here are the key differences in terms of performance and application.
Application
Varnish needs to be applied evenly to avoid streaks or an uneven finish. Stain can also be difficult to apply evenly, but it’s easier to achieve a consistent finish with stain than with varnish.
Water-based varnish is the easiest type of varnish to apply evenly. However, it requires more surface preparation than oil-based varnish.
Color
Varnish is available in clear, semi-transparent, and opaque colors. It can also be tinted to match the color of the wood. Stain is available in a wide range of colors, from light to dark.
Preserving the Natural Appearance of Wood
If your goal is to preserve the natural appearance of your wood, varnish is a great choice. This finish provides a clear, glossy surface that enhances the natural beauty of your wood while protecting it from damage.
Changing the Color or Appearance of Wood
On the other hand, if you’re looking to change the color or appearance of your wood, stain is the better option. With a wide range of colors to choose from, you can use stains to create a unique and eye-catching look that will stand out in your home.
Outdoor Use and UV protection
Both varnish and stain are great options for outdoor use, but varnish provides the best protection against UV light, which can cause fading and yellowing over time. The varnish is the better option if you’re looking for an outdoor finish that will provide a long-lasting, highly reflective surface.
Cost
When it comes to cost, varnish, and stain are relatively similar, with both options available at a wide range of price points, depending on the quality and type of product you choose. However, varnish may be slightly more expensive, especially if you opt for a high-quality, professional-grade product.
Maintenance
Both varnish and stain require some degree of maintenance to keep them looking their best, but varnish is generally the more low-maintenance option. With a high-quality varnish, you’ll only need to reapply the finish every few years, while stain may require more frequent touch-ups, especially if you’re using it in a high-traffic area or outdoors.
Rot prevention
Varnish is more effective than stain at preventing rot. Varnish creates a barrier that prevents moisture from penetrating the surface of the wood.
How to Apply Varnish In Simple Steps
Applying varnish and stain are not complicated processes, but there are some key differences that you should be aware of when deciding which option to use. Here is a breakdown of how to apply varnish and stain and some of the other options you may encounter.
To apply varnish, you will need the following:
- A clean, dry, lint-free cloth
- A dust-free environment
- Mineral spirits (optional)
Step 1: Begin by ensuring that the surface you will work on is clean and dry. If any dirt or debris is present, use a clean, dry, lint-free cloth to remove it.
Step 2: Once the surface is clean, make sure that you are working in a dust-free environment. Dust can cause streaks or bubbles in the varnish, so it’s important to avoid it if possible.
Step 3: Next, select the type of varnish you will be using. There are many different types of varnish available on the market, so consult a professional if you are unsure which one to use for your project.
Step 4: Once you have selected the appropriate varnish, pour a small amount into a container that can be easily disposed of when finished. It’s important only to pour out as much as you think you will need so that there is no waste.
Step 5: Using a clean, dry, lint-free cloth, dip it into the container of varnish and then apply it to the surface in long strokes in the same direction. Be sure to work quickly and evenly to avoid any streaking or unevenness.
Step 6: Allow the first coat of varnish to dry completely before applying a second coat. Additional coats may be necessary depending on the type of varnish being used and the desired results. Refer to the manufacturer’s instructions for specific guidance.
Step 7: Once all coats of varnish have been applied and have had time to dry completely, remove any excess with a clean cloth dipped in mineral spirits (if necessary).
RELATED: Can You Polyurethane Over Varnish? Advise By A Pro
How to Apply Stain
You’ll need the following tools and materials to apply stain:
- Stain (oil-based or water-based)
- Paintbrush or foam brush
- Clean rags
- Mineral spirits (for oil-based stain)
Step 1: Figure out what type of stain you want to use. There are oil- and water-based stains and each has its own benefits and drawbacks. Once you’ve decided on a stain, read the instructions on the can read carefully before beginning.
Step 2: Prepare your wood. If the wood is new, sand it down until it’s smooth. If the wood is already finished, you’ll need to rough it up a bit so that the stain will adhere properly. Once the wood is prepped, wipe it down with a damp cloth to remove any dust or debris.
Step 3: Apply the stain. Use a brush or rag for best results, and work in small sections. Apply the stain evenly, then wipe away any excess with a clean cloth. Allow the stain to dry completely before moving on to the next step.
Step 4: If you want a more durable finish, you can apply a layer of varnish over the top of the stain once it’s dry. This will help protect your work from wear and tear and keep it looking good for years to come.
RELATED: Answered: Can You Stain Over Polyurethane?
Stain vs Varnish vs Lacquer
There are three main wood finish types: stain, varnish, and lacquer. Each has its own advantages and disadvantages, so choosing the right one for your project is important.
Stain is a pigmented finish that penetrates into the wood, giving it color without obscuring the grain. It’s ideal for projects where you want to show off the natural beauty of the wood. However, the stain can be difficult to apply evenly, and it doesn’t provide much protection against wear and tear.
Varnish is a clear finish that sits on top of the wood. It enhances the grain and color of the wood while providing good protection against scratches and stains. However, varnish can yellow over time and is susceptible to chipping and flaking.
Lacquer is a clear or colored finish that dries quickly and provides a hard, durable surface. It’s perfect for projects that will see a lot of wear and tear. However, lacquer can be difficult to repair if it gets damaged.
Tinted Varnish vs Stain
Tinted varnish and stain are two options for adding color to wood surfaces. The key difference between these options is that tinted varnish is a clear finish with a hint of color, while stain is a tinted liquid that penetrates the wood to change its color. Tinted varnish is a good choice if you want to add a touch of color to your wood while still preserving its natural appearance, while stain is a better option if you want to completely change the color of your wood.
There are a few key differences between tinted varnish and a stain:
- Stain is typically applied to bare wood, while varnish can be applied over an existing finish.
- Stain penetrates into the wood grain, while varnish forms a protective film on the surface of the wood.
- Stain can be applied in multiple coats to build up color, while varnish is usually only applied in one or two coats.
While both tinted varnish and stain can be used to achieve a similar effect, there are a few things to keep in mind when deciding which product to use. If you’re starting with bare wood, stain may be the better option. If you’re working with an existing finish that you want to protect, varnish would be the better choice. And if you’re looking for a more durable finish, varnish is typically more resistant to wear and tear than stain.
Varnish vs Urethane
Urethane and varnish are two of the most popular finishes for wood projects. They both provide a high-gloss, durable finish. Here is the difference between varnish and urethane:
Urethane is a synthetic polymer available in oil- and water-based formulas. It is more durable than varnish, but it can yellow over time. It is also more difficult to apply than varnish.
Varnish is made from natural resins and dries to a hard, glossy finish. It is less durable than urethane but will not yellow over time. Varnish is also easier to apply than urethane.
The key difference between these options is their level of durability and protection. Varnish is a traditional finish that provides a clear, protective surface on the wood. Urethane is a more modern option known for its superior durability and protection. Urethane is a better choice for outdoor use or for areas that receive heavy use.
How Many Coats Of Varnish
There are a few things to consider when deciding how many coats of varnish to apply.
The Type of Wood
The type of wood is an important factor to consider when choosing between varnish and stain. Some woods, such as oak or cherry, are porous and may require a sealer before being finished with varnish or stain. Other woods, such as maple or birch, have a tighter grain and can be finished with either varnish or stain without the need for a sealer.
The Level of Finish You’re Going For
The level of finish you’re going for is another important consideration when choosing between varnish and stain. If you’re looking for a high-gloss finish, varnish is the way to go. Varnish will create a smooth, shiny surface that is easy to clean and maintain. If you’re looking for a more natural look, stain is a better option. Stains come in a range of colors and can be used to enhance the natural beauty of the wood.
The Environment the Finished Piece Will Be In
The environment the finished piece will be in is another important factor to consider when choosing between varnish and stain. If the piece will be exposed to moisture or extreme temperatures, the varnish is a better choice. Varnish is a protective coating that will help prevent warping, cracking and discoloration. If the piece is indoors and protected from the elements, either varnish or stain will work well.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I Use Interior Stain Outdoors?
While interior stains are designed for use in enclosed spaces, they can be used outdoors. However, it is important to note that they may not be as durable as outdoor stains and may fade, peel or crack more quickly when exposed to the elements. Outdoor stains, on the other hand, are specifically designed to provide better protection against the elements and UV rays, making them a better option for outdoor projects.
Can I Use Varnish Over Stain?
Yes, you can use varnish over stain. In fact, this is a common technique for enhancing the durability and protection of the stained wood surface. The stain provides a base color, while the varnish provides a protective layer on top. When applying varnish over stain, make sure to thoroughly clean and sand the surface first to ensure proper adhesion.
Do I Need to Sand Between Coats of Varnish?
Yes, it is recommended to sand between coats of varnish to ensure a smooth and even finish. This will help remove any dust or debris that may have settled on the surface, as well as provide a better surface for the next coat to adhere to.
What’s the Difference Between Oil-Based and Water-Based Stain?
Oil-based stains are made with a solvent that dissolves the pigments and oils in the stain, making it ideal for preserving the natural color of wood. On the other hand, water-based stains are made with water and are known for their quick-drying properties and low VOC emissions.
Is Varnish or Stain Better for a Table Top?
Both varnish and stain can be used on a table top, but the choice will depend on the desired outcome. Varnish provides a hard, durable and long-lasting protective finish, while stain can be used to change the color or appearance of the wood. If the goal is to preserve the natural look of the wood, varnish may be the better option, while if a new color or appearance is desired, stain may be the way to go.
Do I need to varnish after staining?
It is unnecessary to varnish after staining, but it can be a good idea for added protection. Stains are designed to provide a base color and penetrate the wood, but they do not provide a protective layer on top. Varnishing over the stain will provide an additional layer of protection against wear and tear and help extend the piece’s life.
What’s the difference between stain vs varnish wood?
Stain is a type of finish that is used to color and penetrate wood, while varnish is a type of protective finish that is applied on top of the wood to protect it from damage. Stain enhances the natural beauty of wood or changes its color, while varnish protects the wood from scratches, water damage, and other environmental factors.
How long does varnish last?
The longevity of varnish depends on a number of factors, including the type of varnish, the environment it is in, and the level of maintenance it receives. High-quality varnish can last anywhere from 5 to 10 years, but it may need to be reapplied more frequently if exposed to harsh conditions.
What’s the difference between stain vs varnish wood?
The difference between stain and varnish lies in the purpose they serve. Stain is primarily used to color or tint the wood, and enhance its natural grain and texture, while varnish is used as a topcoat to protect the wood from environmental elements and wear and tear. Varnish also gives the wood a glossy or matte finish, which can help to make it more resistant to moisture, heat, and other environmental factors. While stain is absorbed into the wood to color it, varnish sits on top and creates a layer of protection.
How long does varnish last?
The lifespan of varnish depends on several factors such as the type of wood it is used on, the environmental conditions the wood is exposed to, and the quality of the varnish. On average, a high-quality varnish can last from 2 to 5 years, or even up to 10 years, if properly maintained.
Conclusion
In conclusion, varnish and stain are two great options for protecting and enhancing the beauty of your wood projects. Both have their own unique set of pros and cons, and the right choice depends on several factors, such as the type of wood, the level of finish you’re going for, and the environment the finished piece will be in. It’s important to carefully consider each factor to make an informed decision that will provide the best protection and appearance for your wood projects.
Whether you choose varnish or stain, it’s important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions for application and maintenance to ensure the best results. With proper care and maintenance, your wood projects can look great for years to come.
2 thoughts on “Varnish vs Stain: A Comprehensive Comparison”
Comments are closed.